Re: [留言] A Note To The Weepies

看板Tanya (蔡健雅)作者Gallium (back to the beginning)時間15年前 (2010/01/27 01:05)推噓0(0推 0噓 3→)

留言3則, 1人參與討論串3/3 (看更多)

※ 引述《Jassiehs (Tanya不愧是我的心上人呀)》之銘言： : Hi I'm Tanya Chua. This is a note from myself to The Weepies and all fans of : The Weepies. In 2008, I produced and sang a Chinese song called Red High : Heels which ended up with the same tempo, key and had an intro that sounded : similar as The Weepies's song, Take It From Me. It went on to catch the : attention of some music lovers who started making comparisons to these two : songs, challenging the authenticity of both songs from both sides. It : definitely created a very awkward situation for myself when I was first asked : about it, as though admittedly I have heard The Weepies's songs before, I : definitely was not conscious of the similarities nor did I have their song in : mind when I wrote and arranged it. It was only when someone somehow morphed : our songs together that I realized the resemblance in some parts. : As a writer myself, I can understand how protective we can be of our : compositions. Nobody wants to have their songs sounding similar to anyone : else, let alone questioned. So when this comparison got to the ears of The : Weepies, they contacted me and asked for my clarifications as they were very : troubled with the fact that their song was released before mine. After being : asked repeatedly about this, it felt long overdue that I set the record : straight here on my own page and hopefully it will bring some rest and : assurance. : If this has caused any distress and inconvenience to The Weepies or even : raised doubts in anyone in regards to the originality of The Weepies : composition, Take It From Me, I offer my most sincere apology. I'm just a : simple music lover and writer who just wrote what felt natural to me at that : time with no intention to copy The Weepies. I wish The Weepies all the best : in their wonderful music. : Love, Peace and Light : Tanya Chua : ps: please forward this note to anyone who may be concerned or who have : inquired The Weepies about this matter, as I don't really know how to reach : all of you. Thanks. : 源自Tanya myspace留言 : http://www.myspace.com/tanyachuamusicTanya : ----- : 請大家幫忙傳達Tanya的想法!! 可以問一下這個事件的後續發展嗎後來the wippies有沒有針對這個發表啥評論而tanya又有何回應我只是單純覺得這種處境很尷尬想知道tanya跟她所屬的版權公司怎麼針對這個問題處理我覺得tanya應該不是"有意"的抄襲但可能在創作的時候那些聽過的旋律或概念就下意識地流洩出來不知道一般詞曲版權公司對於旗下創作人的創作有沒有一種審查過濾制度儘可能地把這種"無心之過"挑出來畢竟創作人也可能會有盲點忘了這個旋律線似曾相識我不太相信巧合啦但我也相信tanya這種創作人絕對不會去intentionally抄襲畢竟這對創作人是很傷的評價 -- My Blog: http://www.wretch.cc/blog/gallium -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 124.8.0.244 ※ 編輯: Gallium 來自: 124.8.0.244 (01/27 01:07)