D.B.T.T. 各大雜誌 & 網站評分

看板Oasis作者kane316 (gas panic!)時間20年前 (2005/05/25 23:30)推噓1(1推 0噓 0→)

留言1則, 1人參與討論串1/2 (看更多)

這幾天蒐集了各地文章以及雜誌報導整理出目前已知的新專輯評分! 評分當然是看看就好, 分數高不用得意,分數低也不用在意專輯還是自己聽了準, 評分只是拿來宣傳罷了 :) 比較特別的是: 向來支持Oasis的雜誌 (如NME)反而給了低評 Spin, Guitarist這些雜誌反而給了高評! ( 以*表示者, 滿分為五顆星 ) Q : * * * * "If definitely maybe was the distillation of mid-90s lad culture, then DBTT can be viewed as oasis' new man album, a record where they're finally acting their ages." MOJO : * * * * Latin Percussion? Village Green psychedelia? The Velvets? What's going on? Pat Gilbert on that 'difficult' sixth album SPIN : A- "Gallaghers in nearly great album shocker!" Guitarist: * * * * "Oasis might not have the power to change the world any more, there are concrete signs thatsome of the magic has returned to their fingertips" Rolling Stone : * * * 1/2 "Not a comeback, but the Gallaghers stop sinking" Observer : * * * * * "At last, they've rediscovered what made them great" Ultimate guitar: * * * * "Theres more lyrical value and while the voices may have been sound boarded, there are no complaints for the end product" FHM : * * * "Regrettably this nostalgic sounding medley is probably the band's third-best effort to date. But the sad truth is that the world's a better place when Oasis are making decent albums." Allmusic : * * * * 1/2 "Comfortable arrangements and the return of their trademark bravado makes Don't Believe the Truth the closest Oasis has been to great since the summer of Britpop, when they were the biggest and best band in the world" Rock & Folk (法國雜誌) : * * * * "While not reaching for the stars, Oasis have regained a certain class." NME : 6 / 10 "This is a record for Sunday morning recrimination rather than Saturday night hellraising,abandoning the by-numbers stomp of its predecessors for reflective English acoustic music" Maxim : * * "Their latest effort is OK, if only because the songs don't sound like Beatles retreads now they sound like Oasis retreads" The Sun : 7.8 / 10 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.136.222.31