PTT偶像團體區 / LadyGaga

[心得] TEOG MV 各大娛樂網站評論

看板LadyGaga作者 (一生懸命)時間14年前 (2011/06/18 17:44), 編輯推噓31(31推 0噓 58→)
留言89則, 27人參與, 最新討論串1/1
http://idolator.com/5905822/review-revue-lady-gaga-edge-of-glory POP or FLOP? :: Entertainment Weekly’s Music Mix found the video to be refreshing: “This is a return to the stripped-down mean streets fantasy of her ‘LoveGame’ video—no elaborate CGI or Godardian color palette, just Gaga working the camera with old-fashion moxie. Especially after her more literal-minded take on ‘Judas,’ ‘The Edge of Glory’ is also a refreshing retreat to her trademark style of making a video that has absolutely nothing to do with the song.” 《娛樂周刊》：這支MV是GaGa清新簡易風格之作，沒有任何電腦動畫與大膽創新。 尤其接在〈Judas〉之後。 :: PopCrush also enjoyed the clip’s simplistic approach: “Gaga dances her way up and down the steps of the fire escape; it feels like an homage to her days as a struggling artist on the Lower East Side when she literally was on the edge of glory and on the precipice of The Fame.” 《PopCrush》：GaGa在階梯上下來回跳舞，有如向她在下東區奮鬥的日子致敬。 :: The Atlantic asked why the video is “so boring,” but ultimately concluded: “‘Edge of Glory’ is arguably the most bombastic, heart-swelling song on her new album Born This Way; with its video, for once, Gaga may have opted to let the music stand on its own.” 《The Atlantic》：為什麼這MV這麼無聊？GaGa選擇讓這首專輯中最震撼人心的歌曲 如其原貌呈現。 :: Vulture praised Gaga for scaling things back for the visual accompanying her third single off Born This Way: “With the gloriously uncomplicated ‘ Edge of Glory’ as the soundtrack, we finally get to catch our breath for a moment.” 跟上面差不多 :: Pop Dust wondered, “Perhaps after spending way too much money on videos that will never possibly make her anywhere near as much in return, Gaga was advised to scale back and rest on the popularity of the song and her persona alone. But after a series of mind-blowing videos, haven’t we been conditioned to expect much, much more?” 《Pop Dust》：也許在一系列精心製作的MV之後，無法再讓GaGa獲得更驚人評價，才轉 而永這麼簡單的方式呈現，但看完這支MV後，我們不禁要問：就這樣？ :: Meanwhile, PopJustice got right to the point: “Lady Gaga’s video for ‘ The Edge Of Glory’ is no good… We just need to accept that Gaga has released an awful video.” 《PopJustice》：這支MV一點都不好，我們只能接受這個事實：她作出了一個可怕的MV。 :: We Are Pop Slags noted the rumored on-set drama between Gaga and the videos onetime director Joseph Kahn: “We don’t really know what happened but it sounds like both of them threw their toys out of the pram and now look rather silly. But was the video worth all the fuss?” 《We Are Pop Slags》：我們不確定GaGa與Joseph Kahn之間到底發生甚麼事，但聽起 來像是兩個嬰兒從嬰兒車互扔玩具，超蠢。搞得這支MV一團糟。 :: Meanwhile, Us Weekly turned the power over to the people with a poll asking readers if they love or hate the video. So far, the “hates” have it, with 63%. 《Us Weekly》則舉辦了投票，不喜歡MV的人佔了63％。 -- -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.112.233.88
推
06/18 17:47, , 1F
兩個嬰兒從嬰兒車互扔玩具 XDDD
06/18 17:47, 1F
推
06/18 17:55, , 2F
我投大flop一票
06/18 17:55, 2F
→
06/18 17:55, , 3F
媒體酸得時候真的很酸..水能載舟亦能覆舟
06/18 17:55, 3F
推
06/18 18:01, , 4F
lady flop
06/18 18:01, 4F
推
06/18 18:03, , 5F
至少現在大家對她下支MV期待會很低 lol
06/18 18:03, 5F
推
06/18 18:19, , 6F
說不定在為下一支鋪梗 不過犧牲一首好歌 等下一首出來
06/18 18:19, 6F
→
06/18 18:20, , 7F
馬上又捧的跟天一樣高了= =
06/18 18:20, 7F
推
06/18 18:22, , 8F
兩個嬰兒從嬰兒車互扔玩具 XDDD +1
06/18 18:22, 8F
→
06/18 20:34, , 9F
不喜歡+1
06/18 20:34, 9F
→
06/18 20:43, , 10F
搞不好這是炒話題的其中一個手段(亂想)
06/18 20:43, 10F
推
06/18 20:58, , 11F
損人損已的炒話題 GAGA有這麼蠢嗎XDDDDDD
06/18 20:58, 11F
→
06/18 22:52, , 12F
但對照最近的負面大事(百萬認證或是MV)讓人不曉得團隊在
06/18 22:52, 12F
→
06/18 22:52, , 13F
想什麼....
06/18 22:52, 13F
推
06/18 23:03, , 14F
其實這MV對我來說雖然不怎樣，但也不會太爛，因為我看過
06/18 23:03, 14F
→
06/18 23:03, , 15F
更爛的Gimme More！＝＝
06/18 23:03, 15F
推
06/18 23:30, , 16F
要是背後的原因跟popcrush講的一樣的話 其實還蠻感動
06/18 23:30, 16F
→
06/18 23:31, , 17F
希望真的是表現gaga的心路歷程 不然真的是boring到炸
06/18 23:31, 17F
推
06/18 23:40, , 18F
以往Gaga曾出面解釋MV意涵嗎？還蠻想聽聽看她的原意。
06/18 23:40, 18F
→
06/18 23:41, , 19F
不知道為什麼，總覺得這次回歸單純有另一種美感和撼動。
06/18 23:41, 19F
→
06/18 23:43, , 20F
沒特別說意涵,不過倒是在推特上自推很愛這mv
06/18 23:43, 20F
→
06/19 00:27, , 21F
自推就算了吧||| 她不可能自打嘴巴, 想當初Telephone出來
06/19 00:27, 21F
→
06/19 00:27, , 22F
時她也說"I feel bad for Bad Romance"(我為BR難過, 因為
06/19 00:27, 22F
→
06/19 00:28, , 23F
新MV Telephone太讚了) 不過BR其實是無法超越的經典了,
06/19 00:28, 23F
→
06/19 00:28, , 24F
但我還是很期待下一支MV, 她應該會來個反撲吧!!!
06/19 00:28, 24F
→
06/19 00:29, , 25F
其實我當初會喜歡上Gaga也是因為B.R.的MV，當中火焰特效
06/19 00:29, 25F
→
06/19 00:29, , 26F
讓我憋笑很久，可是後來想想那支確實很經典，整個很搭！
06/19 00:29, 26F
→
06/19 00:30, , 27F
BR在我心中已經跟Thriller一樣的經典
06/19 00:30, 27F
→
06/19 00:31, , 28F
不過Gaga離Queen of Pop還有很長一段路要走
06/19 00:31, 28F
→
06/19 00:31, , 29F
真的覺得可惜了這首歌~(專輯內的最愛)不是這首該有多好!!
06/19 00:31, 29F
→
06/19 00:34, , 30F
我覺得媒體對她好好喔說實話
06/19 00:34, 30F
推
06/19 00:34, , 31F
可是MV也就是一種紀念性的表演，我是覺得能夠親自表現出
06/19 00:34, 31F
→
06/19 00:34, , 32F
自己心中的意象，就很棒！不論最後成品怎樣，只要發自內
06/19 00:34, 32F
→
06/19 00:35, , 33F
心的表演，我都會用力鼓掌叫好！因為Gaga不也是一直要我
06/19 00:35, 33F
→
06/19 00:36, , 34F
們勇敢做自己嗎？那又何必在乎外界眼光呢？做自己最棒！
06/19 00:36, 34F
推
06/19 00:38, , 35F
樓上的推文... 2140篇說的是你嗎?
06/19 00:38, 35F
推
06/19 00:45, , 36F
shieldsky，其實我覺得這樣單純風格的MV也不錯，只是她
06/19 00:45, 36F
→
06/19 00:46, , 37F
一直要用下腰展現原本柔軟度普普的她極積拉筋的成果讓我
06/19 00:46, 37F
→
06/19 00:46, , 38F
覺得很蠢而己！＝＝
06/19 00:46, 38F
→
06/19 00:48, , 39F
樓上說的內容讓我想到珍芳達!!!!XD
06/19 00:48, 39F
→
06/19 00:51, , 40F
其實我也覺得沒必要去下腰..Gaga有自己特點說..
06/19 00:51, 40F
→
06/19 00:51, , 41F
媒體真的對她很好啊！其實我看到外國網站也沒有作出甚麼
06/19 00:51, 41F
→
06/19 00:52, , 42F
批判...頂多就只說這MV很無聊...但明眼人都看得出來這MV
06/19 00:52, 42F
→
06/19 00:53, , 43F
不符合三單的規格吧!!尤其是要來救flop的judas～看看KP
06/19 00:53, 43F
→
06/19 00:53, , 44F
到第五單都還這拍得這麼誇張！
06/19 00:53, 44F
→
06/19 00:56, , 45F
會被批判還有個原因是因為跟原來導演不合..很可惜
06/19 00:56, 45F
→
06/19 01:06, , 46F
這個時機跌倒總比危險的時候跌倒好..
06/19 01:06, 46F
→
06/19 01:06, , 47F
如果能清醒就好了 等哪天危險邊緣還跌那可不是說爬起就爬起的
06/19 01:06, 47F
推
06/19 01:09, , 48F
我沒有要婊誰啦XDDD 總之...開心就好。
06/19 01:09, 48F
推
06/19 01:13, , 49F
To e0004252:其實我不曉得還有哪裡可以討論Gaga耶……
06/19 01:13, 49F
→
06/19 01:14, , 50F
我進一步認識Gaga也是從這個版開始的；每個人感受不同嚕
06/19 01:14, 50F
→
06/19 01:15, , 51F
！端看自己如何去解釋她所要表達的內容而已。　：）
06/19 01:15, 51F
推
06/19 01:21, , 52F
其實我很受不了的是 那些人一直跳針說：用心點看
06/19 01:21, 52F
→
06/19 01:21, , 53F
啊 我真的就沒看出這MV要表達什麼啊
06/19 01:21, 53F
→
06/19 01:21, , 54F
直到看GAGA自己PO文 才知道這MV到底是在幹嘛
06/19 01:21, 54F
→
06/19 01:23, , 55F
那這MV是在幹嘛?? 不如出一本文字書就好了 = =
06/19 01:23, 55F
→
06/19 01:25, , 56F
以後如果談到她的歌你喜歡哪首或許會有這一首，但我會選Y
06/19 01:25, 56F
→
06/19 01:25, , 57F
擇性忽略這是MV存在的事實，還是場悲劇。
06/19 01:25, 57F
→
06/19 01:25, , 58F
支
06/19 01:25, 58F
推
06/19 01:34, , 59F
如果是人魚故事的梗也很合TEoG，真搞不懂GaGa在想什麼
06/19 01:34, 59F
→
06/19 01:35, , 60F
希望GaGa能清醒啊Q_Q
06/19 01:35, 60F
推
06/19 01:38, , 61F
不過會不會因為這樣跟我搶4000張票的人數變少？XD(毆爛)
06/19 01:38, 61F
推
06/19 13:14, , 62F
Katy Perry的Last Friday Night MV拍得真的很有趣 XD
06/19 13:14, 62F
→
06/19 13:16, , 63F
還請來Rebecca Black參與演出 唉 希望GAGA下一支MV能更好
06/19 13:16, 63F
推
06/19 13:42, , 64F
Katy Perry最近尺度越放越開了XDDD
06/19 13:42, 64F
→
06/19 14:37, , 65F
Katy的尺度本來就很開呀 看他的MV完全不用思索
06/19 14:37, 65F
→
06/19 14:38, , 66F
推樓上XD
06/19 14:38, 66F
推
06/19 15:54, , 67F
害我好像要他拍peacock的MV
06/19 15:54, 67F
推
06/19 18:30, , 68F
我只能說我這輩子還沒看過有哪一位歌手只因為拍了一隻
06/19 18:30, 68F
→
06/19 18:31, , 69F
較樸素的音樂錄影帶就引起軒然大波，卡卡太特別了。
06/19 18:31, 69F
推
06/19 18:42, , 70F
老實說，那MV不叫樸素，應該講她是一個「作業」不是作品
06/19 18:42, 70F
→
06/19 18:43, , 71F
即使裡頭有中心思想，但MV手法實在不敢恭維
06/19 18:43, 71F
→
06/19 18:43, , 72F
不過講再多，信徒依舊崇拜，依舊有解套的說法
06/19 18:43, 72F
推
06/19 18:46, , 73F
胃口大這倒不是真正的問題，覺得有沒有誠意才是。
06/19 18:46, 73F
推
06/19 18:51, , 74F
要說這MV涵義有多深遠的話，會讓人覺得只是空口說白話
06/19 18:51, 74F
→
06/19 18:52, , 75F
也就是你在白紙上，只畫了一個圓圈，然後講它是環保概念
06/19 18:52, 75F
推
06/19 18:57, , 76F
實際上，它只是你為了交差，亂畫的一個圓而已
06/19 18:57, 76F
→
06/19 19:07, , 77F
科 有些人就是太期待 才會現在這麼崩潰
06/19 19:07, 77F
推
06/19 19:11, , 78F
對偶像不期待的話，那就沒必要說這麼多想法了
06/19 19:11, 78F
→
06/19 19:12, , 79F
難道對GAGA存有期待是不應該的嗎...@@? 那太可悲了
06/19 19:12, 79F
→
06/19 19:15, , 80F
看得出樓上很執著XD 每個人都有自己面對的方式 解套是其一
06/19 19:15, 80F
→
06/19 19:16, , 81F
錯了 是樓樓上 我的意思是"太"期待 以致崩潰到無法接受
06/19 19:16, 81F
→
06/19 19:17, , 82F
任何平價的評語 例如:樸素
06/19 19:17, 82F
推
06/19 19:25, , 83F
ok...也許是論壇那篇分析文讓我太傻眼了
06/19 19:25, 83F
推
06/19 19:33, , 84F
不過，我認為樸素不是很恰當的形容，評價的簡易風比較好
06/19 19:33, 84F
→
06/19 19:34, , 85F
畢竟她在mv裡跳的舞、裝扮、整個畫面…實在 = =
06/19 19:34, 85F
→
06/19 20:32, , 86F
我笑了XD 真的很特別齁齁
06/19 20:32, 86F
推
06/20 10:10, , 87F
推shieldsky
06/20 10:10, 87F
推
06/20 22:15, , 88F
推人魚梗，還有我也覺得她拍Peacock MV一定超適合，就像
06/20 22:15, 88F
→
06/20 22:16, , 89F
她在SNL搞笑盯著JT和TLI的下體那樣！XDDDDD
06/20 22:16, 89F
‣ 更多 flyhigher 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1D_7EG8q (LadyGaga)
LadyGaga 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT偶像團體區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 flyhigher 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1D_7EG8q (LadyGaga)